Stan B. Walters | The Lie Guy®

813-820-3079

Monday–Friday · 9 AM–5 PM Eastern

Stan B. Walters | The Lie Guy®

813-820-3079

Monday–Friday · 9 AM–5 PM Eastern

Solving the problem of outdated investigative interview methods
that sabotage investigations.

Choices made in the interview room eventually play out in a courtroom.™

Evidence-based interview and interrogation courtroom scene with TheLieGuy logo representing interview decisions and courtroom consequences.
Investigative interviews. Two people sit across an interview table as a third watches from the foreground. Above them, the title reads “Before You Ask What Happened.”

Before You Ask What Happened

by Stan B. Walters

Interested in hosting a Mastering Investigative Interviews course for your agency? Host a course.

Investigative Interviews:
Before You Ask What Happened

Whether you’re interviewing a victim, a witness, or a suspect, the first minute is a chance to explain what you need from them and why it matters. In my LLRMI article *Reciprocity in the Interview Room*, I asked what an interviewer can give before asking for something. You can give the person a clear idea of what’s expected. Ask them to commit to being honest, tell them why even a small detail matters, and make sure the facts in their account come from them.

Ask for a Commitment to Honesty
Give the person a chance to make that commitment in their own words. “Can you commit to being honest with me about what you remember, including telling me when you’re unsure?” Then pause and let them answer. Explain how that helps them. “If you’re unsure about something, say so. That helps me get your account right.” You’re asking for a commitment they can keep even when their memory is incomplete.

Remind Them the Small Details Matter
The person across from you is making decisions about what to tell you. They may leave something out because it seemed ordinary at the time or because they assume you already know it. Give them a reason to include it. “Tell me what happened in your own words. Even if a detail seems small to you, it could mean a lot to me in understanding what happened.” Then give them room to tell you what they remember.

Keep YOUR Facts Out of THEIR Account
Suppose you already have information that a blue pickup was parked outside. If you ask, “Where was the blue pickup parked?” you’ve supplied the vehicle, its color, and its presence. Start with “What do you remember seeing outside?” If the person mentions a vehicle, ask them to describe it. That keeps the follow-up grounded in what they’ve told you and gives you an account you can compare with the information you already have.

Give Before You Ask
Before you ask what happened, get a commitment to honesty and let the person know that details they might ordinarily skip are worth sharing. Then honor that opening in the way you ask your questions. Make room for uncertainty, follow up on details the person introduces, and leave your own facts out of their account. When you review the interview later, you should be able to trace each fact in that account back to the person who gave it.

"Choices made in the interview room eventually play out in a courtroom™"

© Copyright 2026 by Stan B. Walters All RIghts Reserved

Brief excerpts may be quoted with attribution and a link to the original article.
Reproduction, redistribution, or use in training materials requires written permission.

Check out Stan's YouTube Channel